Skip to main content
Bernstein Burkley
  • Practice Areas
    • Overview
    • Bankruptcy & Restructuring
    • Business and Corporate Transactions
    • Creditors’ Rights
    • Litigation
    • Oil & Gas and Energy
    • Real Estate
  • Our Attorneys
  • About Us
    • Our Approach
    • History
    • Law Lists
    • Professional Memberships
    • Careers
  • Resources
    • Bernstein’s Dictionary of Bankruptcy Terminology
    • Links
    • Five Minute Legal Master videos
    • Blog
    • Legal Publications
  • News
    • Cases Archive
    • Firm News
    • In the News
    • Industry News
  • Contact
CALL - 412 456 8100
Connect
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
Bernstein Burkley
  • Practice Areas
    • Overview
    • Bankruptcy & Restructuring
    • Business and Corporate Transactions
    • Creditors’ Rights
    • Litigation
    • Oil & Gas and Energy
    • Real Estate
  • Our Attorneys
  • About Us
    • Our Approach
    • History
    • Law Lists
    • Professional Memberships
    • Careers
  • Resources
    • Bernstein’s Dictionary of Bankruptcy Terminology
    • Links
    • Five Minute Legal Master videos
    • Blog
    • Legal Publications
  • News
    • Cases Archive
    • Firm News
    • In the News
    • Industry News
  • Contact
Cases

TJX Companies (Ames Dept. Stores)

Representation: Landlord of Ames Department Stores, Inc.

Bankruptcy – Southern District of New York

Situation: Ames Department Stores, Inc., purchased substantially all of the assets and business of the Zayre Stores Division of TJX. Among the assets of the Zayre Stores Division transferred to Ames were various leases. Among those leases was one for which a Bernstein and Bernstein, P.C., client was the landlord.

Although the lease was assigned to Ames, TJX remained obligated under the lease in the event that Ames should default. On the other hand, the purchase agreement between Ames and TJX required Ames to indemnify TJX for any damages which TJX may suffer as a result of Ames’ breach under the lease.

Ames, burdened by the debt incurred in the purchase of the Zayre Stores Division, filed for Chapter 11 in the Southern District of New York. Ames immediately began to consolidate its operations, including closing stores and rejecting leases. Among those leases was that of the firm’s client.

Action: Bernstein and Bernstein, P.C. and the client chose to ignore the bankruptcy of Ames and sued TJX in the United States District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania for damages arising out of Ames’ breach of the lease. TJX responded by asking the District Court to refer the civil action to the Bankruptcy Court (in Pittsburgh) as a matter “related to” the Ames bankruptcy proceeding and, further, asking the Court to stay the lawsuit in light of the Ames bankruptcy case. TJX argued that since it was entitled to indemnity from Ames for any liability which may be assessed against it, the civil action was “related to” the Ames bankruptcy proceeding and should be litigated in front of the Bankruptcy Court and/or stayed until the Ames case was resolved.

The case raised significant landlord-tenant and bankruptcy issues. TJX, essentially in the role of a guarantor as a non-debtor third party, was seeking the protection of the Ames bankruptcy without having to file its own bankruptcy. TJX was liable on a number of rejected leases all over the country. In every published opinion on the issue, and in every prior case which had been litigated in the Western District of Pennsylvania, TJX had succeeded in having the matter referred to the Bankruptcy Court in New York. In most of the cases, TJX had also succeeded in obtaining a stay.

Nevertheless, based on the arguments developed by Bernstein and Bernstein, P.C. attorneys, the District Court initially refused to refer the matter to the Bankruptcy Court and then, based on a recent Supreme Court decision, changed its mind. However, once in Bankruptcy Court, Bernstein and Bernstein, P.C. was still able to prevent the transfer of the matter to the Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York and, further, prevented the Court from imposing a stay.

Because of the success in preventing the transfer to New York and the imposing of a stay, payment in full soon followed.

Back to Top
  • Overview
  • Allegheny Motel Inn, Inc.
  • Alpha Housing
  • Arter & Hadden, LLP
  • Benjamin Coal Company
  • Brockway
  • Brownsville General Hospital
  • Cambria Mills Coal Company
  • Criminal Demolition
  • David Weis Jewelers
  • Debois Investment Group
  • Failure to Satisfy Mortgage
  • Ferrell Prior
  • Glosser Bros., Inc.
  • Guaranty for a Friend
  • Hercules Service Corporation
  • I. D. Craig Service Corp.
  • Insulfoams, Inc.
  • Italian Oven, Inc.
  • K. F. Dairies
  • Large International Electrical Supply Distributor
  • Liberty Electronics
  • Major Supplier of Electronic Components
  • Medical Malpractice Verdict
  • MHF Trucking
  • Pittsburgh Press Club
  • Printing equipment recovery
  • Queen City Distributing
  • Ready Mix Concrete Company
  • Securities Fraud Class Action
  • Security Systems Supplier
  • Shotrock, Inc.
  • Spirit Harley-Davidson, Inc.
  • Star-Tron Technology, Inc.
  • TJX Companies (Ames Dept. Stores)
  • Uniflow Manufacturing Co. (Koldraft)
  • Van Huffel Tube Co.
  • Various Personal Injury Claimants
  • Yobe Electric
  • First Century Corporation
  • Consumer Finance Corporation
  • Hathaway and G & K Bakery (Trustee)
Bernstein Burkley

Copyright © 2023 Bernstein-Burkley

best lawyers 2022lawyer of the year Harry Greenfield
ones to watch best lawyers 2022

 

 

Top Bankruptcy Attorney in Cleveland

Links
  • Disclaimer
  • Knowledge Base
  • Privacy Center
  • Site Map

Bernstein-Burkley, P.C.

Phone: 412.456.8100

Fax: 412.456.8135

Email: info@bernsteinlaw.com

Connect